Combat Templates
Where to find it
You can find Combat Templates in the sidebar, under Dynamic Components. The list shows every combat in this book, with its name, location, and validity. Add Combat Template makes a new one, and pressing a row opens it for editing.
The layers of a combat
A combat is built in two places, in this order. First comes each fighter's own Glossary Item. It holds Can fight, the bag, and the fighter's kit: health, moves, shield. Then comes the template, which holds the combat. It says who meets on which side, who the Reader fights as, and what the story does after. A move changed on a Glossary Item changes in every combat that fighter is in.
Before you start
Fighters are set up on their own Glossary Items first. Add Combat Template opens the window only once one Character or Creature has the first two things below. The third decides whether a fighter takes part:
- Fighters with Can fight on. A Character or Creature with Can fight switched on in its Character and Creature settings. The Combatant picker lists every Character and Creature. One without the switch is greyed, with the reason.
- A bag on each fighter. A Container Fact on the fighter's Fact Card. An empty one is enough. The combat needs somewhere to look for the items their moves use up. It is a Fact added from the Fact Card's + menu, with its kind set to Container in Fact settings.
- Combat Settings with a Character Settings card. Health and energy, set in the fighter's Combat Settings window. Add Combat Template does not need it. But a fighter with no Character Settings card is left out when the combat is built, and their Combatant card says so. That card is the whole requirement: a fighter with no Abilities at all is in the combat and passes their turn. That is how you build a statue or a punching bag.
One of the fighters on the Ally side is the one the Reader moves. You pick them under General Settings. The Playable switch plays no part here.
The modals
The editor has a rail down the left. Ready to fight? is at the top, then General Settings, then one card for each group of Combatants. General Settings has two tabs. Overview holds the combat's name, who the Reader fights as, and its switches. Results holds what your story does after Victory and after Defeat. A group card opens the group, where you name it, pick its side and add its Combatants.
Ready to fight? counts the four things a combat needs before anybody can play it, ticked off as you go. First, somebody certain to be on the other side. Second, the fighter your Reader moves. Third, every Combatant with Combat Settings they can fight with. Fourth, a Trigger that opens the combat. Folded at the top of the rail, it says how many are done and the next step, with "Go there". Pressed, it shows all four, each with what to do. Save refuses the first two, with a message saying what is missing. For the third, Save goes grey when a Combatant points at a deleted fighter, or at one whose Can fight is off. The greyed button gives the reason. A Combatant with no Character Settings card still saves, but the combat leaves it out. If it was the only fighter on the other side, the Reader wins the moment the combat opens. Nothing refuses the fourth. A combat no Trigger opens is one your Reader never reaches.
A new combat with one empty Ally group. The next step is a second group on the Foe side, with a fighter in it. The picker lists every Character and Creature in the book. It greys the ones that are not set up, each with the reason on hover. Who the Reader fights as is picked under General Settings. Ready to fight?, at the top of the rail, counts what is still missing and says the next step. Pressed, it says what to do about each one.
The template
- Template name: shown in the list and in any Trigger that opens this combat. Required, up to 70 characters. Pick a name you'll recognise later: "Bar brawl in Nantucket" beats "combat 4".
- The Reader fights as: the fighter your Reader moves. It is one of the saved fighters in an Ally group. Every other Ally is moved by the game, following When the game plays them in its Combat Settings. The Playable switch on a character plays no part here. A combat can hand the Reader a character they did not choose at the start of the book. In a book with two playable characters, each one needs a combat of its own. The pick is required: the template will not save without it.
- Show the combat's name to the Reader: when on, the Reader sees the template name as the heading of the combat. Off keeps the focus on the action.
- Combat leaves a mark: when on, whatever a fighter used up from the bag it brought stays used up after the combat ends. When off, the bag is as it was. Health and effects are not carried either way: every combat starts from the Combat Settings on the Glossary Item. Off suits sparring, a combat in a dream, or any combat whose potions should come back.
- Location: an optional Glossary Item for where the combat happens, shown as a column in your list of Combat Templates. It must be in the Location category, and the editor only offers those. The Reader never sees it.
Groups of Combatants
Up to five groups, three sides
Combatants are organised into groups. A template can hold up to 5 groups. Each group has a name that only you see, for telling them apart. It also has a Side:
- Ally: fights beside the Reader's fighter, the one picked under General Settings.
- Foe: fights against the Reader.
- Wild: on neither side. It attacks Allies and Foes alike. It suits a pack of beasts, or a hostile character.
There is one rule. At least one group on the Foe or Wild side must have no prerequisites. It also needs a Combatant whose own Joins the combat is Always. That way somebody is certainly there to fight. A condition on the card hides that Combatant from the Readers it does not hold for, exactly as a prerequisite on the group does. A new group starts on the Ally side, so a one-group combat cannot be saved yet. The list at the top of the rail counts it. "Ready to fight?" sits at 1 of 4, with "Next: Someone for your Reader to fight". Save refuses with "Your Reader needs someone to fight.".
Prerequisites on a group
A group can have a prerequisites block: conditions that must be true for the group to appear at all. Unlike a Decision Template, there is nothing to choose about the failure case. When the conditions are not met, the group stays out of the combat, and the tab says so at the top. This suits a reinforcement group that should only arrive if the Reader rang the alarm bell three Chapters back. Switching prerequisites off again removes the conditions, and the editor asks first.
Combatants
The Combatants inside each group
A group lists its Combatants on the Combatants tab, up to 10 per group, one card each. Each Combatant points at a Glossary Item from the book. It is a Character or Creature with Can fight turned on and a Container Fact on its Fact Card. The picker lists every Character and Creature in the book. One that is not set up yet is greyed, with the missing thing on hover. A fighter with no Combat Settings yet can be picked. The combat leaves it out until it has some, and the card says so.
A saved Combatant reads back as a sentence: Queequeg joins Queequeg's side. Under it are their health, energy, shield and how many Abilities they have, read off their own Glossary Item. That way an empty fighter is spotted here, not in the middle of a combat. Any of it is changed on that Glossary Item.
What you set for each Combatant on the template:
- Combatant: the Character or Creature Glossary Item this card stands for.
- Their bag for this combat: which of the character's Container Facts they bring to this combat. Its items are what their consumable Abilities can use. An item marked Can be used during combats brings its own moves and its Lasting Effects along. With Combat leaves a mark on, whatever they used up stays used up. A character with two containers, say a backpack and a quiver, can bring different ones to different combats.
- Joins the combat: Always means the Combatant always joins. Only when... brings them in only when something specific is true, such as the Reader's level being above 5 or a particular flag being set.
A card has no Save of its own. Anything that takes you away from it keeps it: adding another card, opening another, or moving to another tab or group. So does Save Combat Template at the bottom, which puts the whole combat in your book. Collapse on the card folds it to one line and keeps it too, but it is never required. Among the cards, only an unfinished one stops Save Combat Template. That is one you started without saying who it is or which bag they bring. Save then names its group.
Outcomes
What runs when the combat ends
A combat ends in one of two outcomes: Victory (every Foe and Wild fighter is down) or Defeat (the Reader's fighter is). Each outcome has its own list of Result Sets: the things that happen to the world once the combat is over. Both panels are open on the Results tab, each with a line saying which case it covers. Only the list under the outcome the combat reached runs. Inside that list, every set whose conditions hold runs, top to bottom. They are not alternatives.
Results work like a Trigger's, with one difference: an outcome cannot open another window. It can reveal a Chapter or Header the Reader could not reach before. (The Story Flow page says what a reveal does.) It can also change a Fact, raise or lower a stat, reveal or hide a Glossary Item, or change many at once. A Dialogue or a Decision after the combat needs a Fact set here, and a Trigger in the Chapter that checks it. A Victory can hand out rewards, set a "village saved" flag, and reveal the next Chapter. A Defeat can reveal a recovery scene with the wounded character's Facts already updated. Nothing drops on its own. A beaten foe hands something over through a Put in result on the Victory outcome, which puts the item into the Reader's Container.
For example: a brawl at the Spouter-Inn
Ishmael and Queequeg come to blows over the bed. This is the combat on the demo's second tab, in the window's own words. On the template, the Name is "A combat the Reader can lose", the Location is The Spouter-Inn, and there are two groups. The group Ishmael's side, on the Ally side, holds one Combatant: Ishmael, bringing Ishmael's sea chest. The group Queequeg's side, on the Foe side, holds Queequeg, bringing Queequeg's harpoons. The Reader fights as Ishmael. On the Results tab, Victory has one result, Reveal the Chapter The Ship. Defeat has one too, Set Ishmael's Luck to 0.
Everything about how hard Queequeg hits is on his own Glossary Item. That is 20 Health Points, 2 Energy Points, and the Harpoon throw from the Combat Settings page. A second Ability added there shows up in this combat without any change here.
What your Reader sees
One combat, turn by turn, in a window over the page. The fighters stand in a strip, grouped under Ally, Foe and Wild, each with a health bar. A Begin Combat button starts it. The combat's name is the heading while Show the combat's name to the Reader is on. Group names and the Location are yours alone.
- A round is everybody taking one turn, in an order drawn afresh each round. At the start of a round, every fighter's energy refills to full and cooldowns tick down one. Lasting Effects do their work too, each with a line in the log. A move costs energy, so a fighter with 2 Energy Points and moves that cost 1 gets two moves a round.
- "Your turn" is when the Reader picks. The buttons are their fighter's Abilities. One that cannot be used right now is greyed, with the reason on it. The energy may be short, or the cooldown still running. Or the move's own rules say no, such as "Only while health is less than 15". A move with a chosen target asks them to tap who. Everyone else is moved by the game, following When the game plays them in their Combat Settings.
- It ends on Victory or Defeat, in big letters, with a Continue button. The outcome's results run when the Reader presses it. There is no fleeing and no draw. Victory is every Foe and Wild fighter down, and Defeat is the Reader's fighter down. The combat runs until one of those is true.
The window holds the page: the Reader can minimize it and look back, but they read on only once the combat is over.
Published templates
Once a Combat Template is published, it locks. Its card in the list shows a lock and no longer opens. Duplicate, which appears when you hover over the card, makes a copy with (Copy) added to the name, and the copy can be edited.
The published one changes in an Edition, started from your Published page. There it opens while the Edition works on the part it was published with, and your change goes out with the Edition when you publish it. The Publishing page says what Readers in the middle of the book see.
Validation
A Combat Template can become invalid for several reasons. The list page marks broken templates with a warning icon and sorts them to the top. The publish check rejects any book that contains an invalid Combat Template.
- The location points at a Glossary Item that has been deleted, or one that's no longer in the Location category. Pick a different one or clear the field.
- A Combatant points at a Glossary Item that has been deleted, or one where Can fight has since been turned off. Picking somebody else on that card fixes it. When Can fight was turned off, switching it back on fixes it too.
- The Reader fights as names nobody in the combat. The fighter was removed, or its group was turned into a Foe. Or nobody is picked, and no Ally in the combat is Playable. A new pick under General Settings fixes it.
- A group's prerequisites or a Combatant's conditions reference a Glossary Item, Fact, Tag, or Calculation that has since been deleted. The broken row is flagged so you can jump to it.
- A group has Only let this group join when... switched on but no prerequisites written. Writing the conditions fixes it, and so does switching it off.
- An outcome result targets a Chapter, Header, Glossary Item, Fact, or Tag that has since been deleted. Re-pointing the row in that outcome fixes it.
Before a Combat Template is deleted, a question over its window lists the Triggers that still open it. "Keep it" changes nothing. "Delete anyway" leaves each of them marked broken until it opens something else. The book can't be published while one is broken. There is no undo once it goes.
Questions writers ask
The same questions and answers sit behind the "?" in the Combat Template window.
How this fits your story
How does my Combat Template actually reach my Reader?
It does not, on its own. Building it here only makes it available. Something in the story has to start it.
That something is almost always a Trigger. A Trigger is an invisible checkpoint inside a Chapter, added from the "+" menu in the editor like any other block. When your Reader reaches that line, the Trigger checks what they have done so far. It can then open this Combat Template.
A Trade Screen and a Dice Template each have one more way in. A reply in a Dialogue Template can open a Trade Screen from its own results. That is how a conversation leads into a shop. A Decision Template choice or a Combat Ability can roll a Dice Template with its "Roll a dice:" switch.
No other result opens a Dynamic Component. A choice, a dice outcome or a combat's outcome sets a Fact instead, and a Trigger that checks it does the rest.
So it is built here. Its Trigger goes in the Chapter where it should happen (The Ship, for instance), at the moment you want it.
What is the difference between a condition and a result?
A condition, under "When", is a question about what your Reader has already done. A result, under "Then", is a change that happens once the answer is yes.
"Has the Reader seen The Ship?" is a condition. "Reveal The Ship" is a result. The same thing can appear on either side, which makes them easy to mix up. One asks about it, and the other changes it.
Both are built the same way, in the same order, everywhere in Verhaler. First comes what the row is about, then what to ask or what to do.
If I add several conditions, do all of them have to be true?
All of them. Rows are only ever joined with And. There is no "Or" anywhere in the builder.
"Either of these" takes two separate Result Sets, each with one condition and the same result.
Up to 10 conditions in one group.
What is the first box in a row, the one that asks what should be checked or changed?
It picks what the row is about.
In a condition, that is a Chapter or a Glossary Item. The dice roll and an Emotion are offered too, where the window you are in allows it.
In a result, it is the thing you want to change: a Chapter, a Glossary Item, or many of them at once ("Many at once"). Where the window you are in allows it, it can also be a Dynamic Component to open.
The boxes after it narrow down what you picked, so they only make sense once the first one is filled.
Can one result put several Items in a bag, or take them out?
Yes. A "Put in" on a Container Fact can name up to 200 Items, each with its own amount.
A "Take out" of one Item takes the amount it names. A "Take out" of several takes all of each.
What is the difference between "The whole Chapter" and one of its Headers, or "The item itself" and one of its Facts?
The whole thing, not one of its parts.
The Ship with "The whole Chapter" means the Chapter itself. A Header instead means only that part. On a Glossary Item, "The item itself" means the item, as against one of its Facts or one section of its page. When the row is about the Reader, the same choice reads "The Reader themselves".
When there is nothing inside to choose from, that box is not shown at all. The whole thing is the only answer, so it is taken for you.
Why did my result disappear after I saved?
A set whose result row was never filled in is not saved. Under Always, a Trigger says "Nothing to save yet. Pick at least one result first". It says "A few of these are still empty, so nothing was saved yet" under Only when... instead. Elsewhere, the empty set is quietly dropped when you save the window. That is the usual reason a result seems to vanish after saving.
What do "Always" and "Only when..." mean?
They decide whether the results need conditions at all.
Always: the results happen every time, and there is no "When" block to fill. Only when...: they happen only when every condition under "When" is true. The one that is pressed in is the one you are in.
What does revealing or hiding something do to my Reader?
Chapters, Headers and Glossary Items can start out hidden, and stay out of your Reader's reach until something reveals them.
A reveal result on The Ship lets them get to it. A hide takes it away again. The condition "is revealed" asks about that same state. That is how one part of your story can depend on another having happened.
When do the results on the Results tab run?
When the combat ends, based on how it ended. Victory is every Foe and Wild fighter down. Defeat is the Reader's fighter down. Each outcome holds up to 20 Result Sets, each with its own conditions. So winning and losing can lead somewhere different. Victory might reveal The Ship, and Defeat might set Caught sneaking to False.
This is the only place the combat touches the rest of your story, unless "Combat leaves a mark:" is on. A combat with an empty Results tab happens and then changes nothing.
An outcome can't open another window. A Dialogue Template or a Decision Template after the combat needs a Fact set here. A Trigger in the Chapter then checks that Fact and opens it.
This window's own settings
What does my Reader see?
One combat, turn by turn. Your Reader sees the fighters in a strip, grouped under Ally, Foe and Wild, and a "Begin Combat" button. Then come the rounds, with a line for each move. "Your turn" shows when it is theirs, with their fighter's moves to pick from. It ends on a big "Victory" or "Defeat" with a Continue button. The story then carries on with whatever the Results tab says.
The combat's name is the heading over all of that while "Show the combat's name to the Reader:" is on. Off, there is no heading. The group names and the Location are yours alone. Your Reader never sees them.
What is "Ready to fight?" counting?
The four things a combat needs before anybody can play it, at the top of the rail on the left. Folded, it says how many are done and names the next one, with a short sentence and "Go there". Pressing it shows all four, each with what to do about it.
The first is somebody certain to be on the other side. That is a group on the Foe or Wild side, with no Prerequisites. It holds a saved Combatant whose "Joins the combat" is Always. The second is the fighter your Reader moves. The third is Combat Settings on every Combatant, so they can fight. The fourth is a Trigger that opens the combat.
Save refuses the first two, with a message saying what is missing. For the third, Save goes grey when a Combatant points at a deleted fighter, or at one whose "Can fight" is off. A Combatant with no Combat Settings still saves, but the combat leaves it out. If it was the only fighter on the other side, the Reader wins the moment the combat opens. Nothing refuses the fourth.
The count is read from what is in the window right now. An open Combatant card is not in it yet. It joins the group when you add another card, open another, or leave its tab or group, and the count follows. The first three checks read only collapsed Combatant cards.
What do Ally, Foe and Wild mean?
A combat is made of groups, and "Side:" says which side a group is on. The rail on the left shows the same three icons beside every group.
Ally fights beside your Reader's fighter. Foe fights against them. Wild is on nobody's side. It attacks Allies and Foes alike, like a bear in a burning barn.
Wild suits a combat where the real question is who gets out. Victory is every Foe and Wild fighter down. Defeat is the Reader's fighter down.
Who does my Reader play in the combat?
The fighter picked under "The Reader fights as:" in General Settings. That is the one your Reader moves each round. The game moves every other Ally, following "When the game plays them:" in its Combat Settings.
The pick is per combat, and the "Playable" switch on a Character plays no part in it. A combat can hand your Reader a character they did not choose at the start of the book. In a book with two playable characters, each one needs a combat of its own.
Only a saved fighter in an Ally group can be picked, so the fighter comes first. It also needs Combat Settings on its Glossary Item, or the combat leaves it out. If the same character sits in two Ally groups, both rows are the Reader's. Defeat is when all the Reader's fighters are down.
The picked fighter also has to turn up. A group with Prerequisites, or a fighter set to "Only when...", can be left out of combat. A combat with no fighter of the Reader's in it plays itself out as a scene, and is lost when every Ally is down. So the pick is best kept in a group with no Prerequisites, or the combat opened only where they hold.
What is "Their bag for this combat", and why must every Combatant have one?
Which of that character's Container Facts they carry into this combat. Somebody can have a backpack and a weapon belt. This says which one is on them today.
The combat reaches into it for anything used up. An Item marked "Can be used during combats" also brings its moves in from it. That is why every fighter needs one.
Where do I set health, energy and abilities?
Not here. They belong to the Glossary Item, in its own Combat Settings, because they are true of that character in every combat. The button appears in the item's side panel once "Can fight" is on.
So one wolf's health is written once, and every combat with that wolf in it uses it. This window only decides who turns up, on whose side, and what the combat changes when it ends. A fighter with no Combat Settings at all is left out of the combat. The Combatant card says so once you pick it.
The numbers can be read without leaving. A saved Combatant row shows its fighter's health, energy, shield and number of Abilities, under the sentence.
What does "Combat leaves a mark" do?
Yes: whatever was used up from a fighter's bag, the Container Fact it brought, stays used up when the combat ends. Health and effects are not carried over. Every combat starts from the Combat Settings on the Glossary Item.
No: the combat is self-contained and only its outcome results take effect. Your Reader walks away as they came in, except for whatever you wrote on the Results tab.
No is right for a set-piece you want to be able to lose without wrecking the rest of the book. Yes is right when the story is about attrition.
What are a group's Prerequisites, and why is that tab greyed out?
They decide whether that group turns up at all. A group of guards with a Prerequisite is only in the combat when the Prerequisite is true. That is how one Combat Template covers "you were quiet" and "you were not". A group that is left out is not there at all, and your Reader never sees it.
Greyed out, the tab points at "Only let this group join when...:" above it. Once that is set to Yes, the tab opens. Switching it back to No removes the conditions, after asking first.
A fighter's own "Joins the combat:" switch is a smaller version of the same idea. Always means always in. Only when... means only when its own conditions hold. So a squad can always turn up while one member appears only if, say, a Fact is True.
Can the same character be in two groups, or twice in one?
Yes to both. The list does not stop you. Each row is its own fighter in the combat, with its own health. So two rows of the same wolf make a pack of two. Two different people need two Glossary Items. Otherwise the rows share one name and one set of Combat Settings.
The same character in two Ally groups, behind opposite Prerequisites, is how one combat covers two versions of the scene. If that character is who the Reader fights as, both rows are the Reader's.
How many groups, Combatants, conditions and Result Sets can a combat hold?
Five groups, with ten Combatants in each. A group's Prerequisites hold 10 conditions, and so does a Combatant's "Only when...". Victory and Defeat each hold 20 Result Sets. Each button says when it is full.
What is "Location" for?
Your own note of where the combat happens, as a Location Glossary Item. It shows as a column in your list of Combat Templates, so you can tell the ford from the mill later. Your Reader does not see it, and a combat works without one.
When something looks wrong
"Add another" has stopped doing anything. Why?
You have reached a cap. One group holds up to 10 conditions, and one Result Set holds up to 10 results.
More Result Sets can carry more, each with its own conditions and results.
Why can't I edit this Combat Template any more?
Four locks, and each says which one it is.
"This Combat Template is published, so no change is possible." It changes in an Edition, started from your Published page. A locked card in the list will not open at all. "Duplicate", the copy icon that appears when you hover over the card, makes a copy you can change, and your Readers keep the original.
"This Combat Template is your draft for the next Expansion." An Edition is open, and what you wrote before it waits until it is published or discarded.
"This Combat Template is part of the original story." Or of an Expansion: the lock names the part. An Edition works on one part at a time. "Work on another part" with Switch, in the banner at the top of the page, moves it there.
A lock on the whole book. The banner at the top of the page says why, and its button leads to where the book opens again.
What happens if I delete a Combat Template something else is using?
Nothing silently breaks. Before it goes, a question over the window lists what still uses it, a Trigger that opens it included. "Keep it" changes nothing, and "Delete anyway" deletes it. Each of those then shows as broken, with a warning icon on it, until you pick something else there or remove it. The book can't be published while one is broken.
A delete can't be undone.
How do I check that any of this works?
In a Reading Simulation, by reading past the point where it should happen.
The sidebar's Trigger Log lists every Trigger you passed. "What it checked and changed", under a Trigger in the log, shows each condition marked Passed or Failed, and each result Applied or Skipped. That tells you whether the problem is your condition or your result.
It refuses to save: "Your Reader needs someone to fight".
There has to be somebody your Reader is certainly fighting. "Ready to fight?" at the top of the rail leaves this one unticked until there is.
A new group starts on the Ally side. In this combat, every Foe and Wild group falls short. Each has Prerequisites on it, or nobody in it, or nobody whose own "Joins the combat" is Always. So it is possible for no enemy to turn up. A combat with nobody to fight is won the moment it opens, and the Victory results run.
The fix is one group whose "Side:" is Foe or Wild, with "Only let this group join when...:" left at No. It needs at least one saved Combatant whose "Joins the combat" is Always. That group is the combat. The conditional ones are the reinforcements, whether the condition sits on the group or on the card.
It refuses to save: "Pick who the Reader fights as" or "Add a fighter to an Ally group".
There has to be somebody your Reader is. A combat with no fighter of theirs in it plays itself out without them.
The pick is under "The Reader fights as:", in General Settings. The list holds the saved fighters of your Ally groups. An empty list means no Ally group has a saved fighter yet. A pick also goes stale when its fighter is removed, or its group turns into a Foe or Wild. The General Settings card and the template list then show the warning until a new pick is made. A template with no pick at all treats every "Playable" Ally as the Reader's. It asks for a pick the next time it is saved.
My hero is greyed out in the "Combatant:" list, or the button would not open at all.
A fighter is not made here. It is a Character or Creature Glossary Item with two things set on it. The list shows every Character and Creature in your book. One that is missing either thing is greyed, and says which when you hover over it.
"Can fight" turned on, in that item's side panel. This is the one people miss.
A Container Fact on its Fact Card, for what it is carrying. A fighter with nothing to carry cannot pick anything up or use anything, so combat has no room for it.
Once both are set on Captain Ahab in the Glossary, they can be picked here. A fighter that says "No Combat Settings yet" under its name still needs its health and moves. Those are set under Combat Settings, on the same panel. Without them, the combat leaves it out.
Is there a Save on the Combatant card? And why is Add Combatant not greyed out?
There is no Save on the card. Anything that takes you away from a Combatant card keeps it. That means adding another card, opening another, moving to another tab or group, or pressing Save Combat Template at the bottom. The Collapse button on the card folds it down to one line. It keeps the card too, but you never have to press it. The same goes for a Result Set on the Results tab.
Add Combatant is not greyed for an open card either. It folds that card away and gives you a new one. Only a card that is not finished stops any of this. That is a card you started without saying who it is, or which bag they bring. The card then says what it is missing, and Save Combat Template stops and names its group. A card you never touched is dropped.
Nothing reaches your book until Save Combat Template.
There is a warning icon and a "Next group to fix" button.
A group somewhere in the combat points at something that was deleted or changed. Groups sit on separate panels, so the button walks you there. Each press jumps to the next group that needs fixing.
The mark comes from a Combatant whose fighter or bag was deleted, or whose fighter has "Can fight" switched off. A rule that points at something deleted does it too. The pencil on the marked row opens it so you can pick again. For a Combatant, Save Combat Template stays greyed until then, and says why when you hover over it.